top of page
  • Writer's pictureRoute 56

Spacious or Private: The Great Debate of Open vs. Closed Floor Plans

Updated: Mar 24, 2023

Are you trying to decide between an open or closed floor plan for your home renovation project? Both options have their pros and cons, so it's important to weigh them carefully before making a decision. In this post, we'll explore the benefits and drawbacks of each, as well as tips for finding the right balance in your home.

Closed Floor Plan

A closed floor plan creates distinct rooms and spaces, each with its own purpose and function. This can provide privacy and separation between different activities and areas of your home, making it easier to concentrate and relax. Here are some other pros and cons of a closed floor plan:


  • Provides more wall space for art and decor

  • Reduces noise and distractions between rooms

  • Offers more privacy for individual rooms

  • Easier to control temperature and humidity in separate rooms


  • Can make smaller homes feel cramped and claustrophobic

  • May limit natural light and airflow in certain areas

  • Can feel outdated or closed off to some homeowners

  • Requires more construction and materials to build separate walls

  • If you're someone who values privacy and needs separate spaces for different activities, a closed floor plan might be the right choice for you. But if you prefer a more open and airy feel, an open floor plan might be a better fit.

Open Floor Plan

Open Concept Floor Plan

An open floor plan removes barriers between rooms, creating a seamless flow between living, dining, and kitchen spaces. This can make a home feel larger and more spacious, as well as enhance natural light and airflow. Here are some other pros and cons of an open floor plan:


  • Creates a more modern and contemporary look

  • Provides flexibility and versatility for furniture arrangement

  • Maximizes natural light and views throughout the home

  • Enhances social interaction and connectivity


  • May be more difficult to control noise and distractions

  • Can feel drafty or cold in certain areas

  • May require more effort to keep clean and organized

  • Can be challenging to incorporate individual spaces and privacy

Finding the Right Balance

So, which is better: an open or closed floor plan? The answer depends on your personal preferences, lifestyle, and needs. But in many cases, the best solution is a balance of both. Here are some tips for finding the right balance:

Determine your needs and priorities. Do you value privacy and individual spaces, or do you prefer a more open and social layout? Think about how you currently use your home, and what changes you'd like to make.

Consider the flow of natural light and views. How can you maximize the natural light and views in your home, while still maintaining some level of privacy and separation? This might involve adding skylights, windows, or even sliding doors.

Get creative with design and decor. Even in an open floor plan, you can create distinct areas and zones with creative design and decor. Use furniture, rugs, and lighting to define different spaces and functions.

Ask for professional advice. A general contractor or interior designer can help you navigate the pros and cons of open and closed floor plans, and find the right balance for your home and budget.

Open Plan or Closed Plan?

  • Open Floor Plan

  • Closed Floor Plan

22 views0 comments


Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page